Hungary: Is This The End Of An Era?
Hungary’s only left authentic news organization has been shaken by an ordeal that stinks of censorship.
More than 70 journalists, 20 of them women, walked out of the Index headquarters on Friday, July 24 en mass resignation to protest the arbitrary dismissal of editor-in-chief Szabolcs Dull. The decision was taken by the president of the board of Index.hu, László Bodolai. We hear from our sources, there has been political intervention.
Index had expressed concern about their independence a few months ago when Miklos Vaszily, a pro-Orban businessman, bought 50% of shares of Index's advertising and revenue. It was then that the team under Szabolcs moved their status as “in danger” from “independent” in their “press freedom barometer”.
”I believe this is the reason that made it very urgent for the political influence needed to fire Szabolcs Dull. We have seen this trend across the board in countries where governments chose to stifle the press. This is a the vivid form of intervention into a democratic institution called the press. We are proud of the journalists who are saying no to this kind of pressure in Hungary, and we stand in solidarity with them,” says CFWIJ founding director Kiran Nazish.
STATEMENTS
HOW THIS AFFECTED WOMEN JOURNALISTS?
The Orban government and its predecessors have been playing a rather “unique” way in silencing the media in Hungary for nearly a decade. Instead of blatantly shutting down opponent news outlets, like we see in much of Eastern Europe, dissolving the critical nature of independent media through economic pressure has been their tactic.
Viktoria Serdült, a journalist for HVG.hu, one of the remaining independent news outlets explained this to the CFWIJ during an interview: “Independent journalism in Hungary in the last decade has been a job that comes with much unpredictability. The newsrooms of public service radio, TV and the state news agency MTI long ago gave up any pretence of impartiality. However privately owned businesses too have been pushed to succumb to government’s wishes through ownership of shares, or in Index’s case taking over the main revenue source, advertisement of newspapers. It is impossible to say when your news outlet will lose financial independence, which comes with losing its independence in reporting. That is why we see many young journalists burnt out not only because of the hard work that they do but due to unpredictability towards the future. I know journalists who gave up on reporting and became gardeners, I have colleagues who express they would rather move to the UK and wait tables. This pressure on the media in a way has not only affected the industry alone but also the aspirations of the public. That is why the Orban government didn’t dare shut down Index via legal pressure, because that would mean a huge decline in their popularity, so they went about it rather sneakily.”
CONCERNED VOICES
LIST OF 20 RESIGNED WOMEN JOURNALISTS
CFWIJ extends solidarity to over 70 journalists at Index, who have resigned to protest the sacking of their editor-in-chief Szabolcs Dull. Among them, 20 are women journalists and we want you to meet them. All these journalists have taken a stand against the arbitrary decision by the management that impedes the liberty and independence of free press. We stand with them in solidarity.
TWITTER CAMPAIGN
(2/4) On July 24, @indexhu staff resigned enmasse calling it “the end of an era”. They cited outside pressure & warned about the decline of independent reporting. The independent news outlet remains one of #Hungary's most-read & trusted news sources for the past 20 years. pic.twitter.com/OXCn0ZT9tm
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 27, 2020
#Hungary: #CFWIJ is utterly appalled by the pressure on independent media in Hungary, yet remains hopeful that acts of solidarity and integrity will prevail. We stand with journalists who stood up for the public’s right to information.
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 28, 2020
Read our statement: https://t.co/ZG3Q04KDZV pic.twitter.com/gWSfUch7PY
(4/4) Media in #Hungary is either state owned or pro government private businesses. After half of @indexhu’s shares were bought by a pro-Orban businessman, the outlet moved its status to “in danger” in their #press #freedom #barometer. pic.twitter.com/grxnjkhiaA
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 27, 2020
#Hungary: #Women #journalists at @indexhu who resigned to protest the dismissal of their editor in chief and pressure on media are standing up for press freedom in the country. CFWIJ extends solidarity with them. pic.twitter.com/IGhr9iPRn0
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 27, 2020
(1/24) #Hungary: More than 70 journalists walked out of @Indexhu headquarters on Friday, July 24 in mass resignation to protest the arbitrary dismissal of editor-in-chief Szabolcs Dull and unprecedented signs of political interference in #news #journalism. pic.twitter.com/InJmQuQZmh
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(3/24) CFWIJ released a statement about the resignation of @Indexhu staff. 20 of them are women journalists. @viktoriaserdult, reporter for @hvg_hu, explained the situation of press freedom to the CFWIJ during an interview.
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
Read our full statement here: https://t.co/xFBdCPnl5F pic.twitter.com/uDZWu7xu2V
(5/24) Deputy editor-in-chief @munkvera who called the arbitrary dismissal a “clear interference” had been working at @indexhu for 18 years. A professor of journalism and media studies, Veronika's exit is a great loss for the media outlet. pic.twitter.com/EbmVEwUBDw
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(7/24) @MariannaBiro covered politics at @indexhu since January 2019 during which time she published 1416 articles. Priorly, Marianna worked at @nepszava and @168_Ora. We need the experience and knowledge of journalists like her. pic.twitter.com/YSKZCpOfPo
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(9/24) Ajpek Orsolya was a photographer at @indexhu covering the beauty of Hungary. She worked as a photojournalist for https://t.co/y4cqxDmJtn, https://t.co/8jryf7Yt4y, then Napi Gazdaság, @168_Ora, and Weekly Answer priorly. pic.twitter.com/tGWyAXTGK3
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(11/24) Egyed Anna was in charge of @indexhu’s social media accounts. She had been working with the team as a project manager for three years. Previously, Egyed worked for @origo_zrt and @hvg_hu. pic.twitter.com/3YIIZrIUDn
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(13/24) Előd Fruzsina’s was the assistant editor for economy pages of @indexhu. She had been working as a journalist @indexhu since May 2015. She stood against the pressure on independent journalism just like her colleagues. pic.twitter.com/Lt4f9TxTtY
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(15/24) Demeter Ági was responsible for back-office at @indexhu. She has taken a stand against the arbitrary decision by the management. pic.twitter.com/C3lWykkqps
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(17/24) Pintér Luca was a politics reporter at @indexhu. The seasoned journalist worked for https://t.co/7zy1gzThyt, Ringier AG, and Magyar televízió in her 10-year-long career and decided to stand in solidarity with her team against Dull’s arbitrary dismissal. pic.twitter.com/RpWAWIndZY
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(20/24) Presinszky Judit was covering policy news with her 16 colleagues. She had been working at @indexhu since 2017 and contributed to over a thousand articles for the news outlet. pic.twitter.com/oonae3oSpn
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(22/24) Thüringer Barbara was working as a newsroom editor at @indexhu for the past two years. She contributed to over eight thousand articles for the news outlet. pic.twitter.com/I7fRS1xWlq
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020
(24/24) Hudak Hajnal was working as the newsroom reporter at @indexhu for 16 years. She also decided to join the mass resignation with her colleagues to protest the editor-in-chief’s sacking. pic.twitter.com/wGQXQQ9dfz
— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) July 29, 2020